Grown By Us
Multi Award Winning
Low Sugar
Low Glycemic Index
Used By Professionals
0
0
Subtotal: $0.00

No products in the cart.

No products in the cart.

Winter Blues or SAD? What Light Does to Your Mood

Frost-covered branches beside winter blues and SAD text
Summarize with AI

About two thousand years ago, the Huangdi Neijing gave one piece of advice for winter that sounds almost modern: 早卧晚起,必待日光. Go to bed early, get up late, and wait for the sunlight. Today we would call that advice about circadian rhythm and morning light. And for a lot of people, it is the most important advice they will get all winter.

As the days shorten, many of us feel it. We sleep more, move less, want bread and sweets, and find it harder to care about things we normally enjoy. For most people that is the “winter blues,” and it passes. For some, it is something more serious with a name: seasonal affective disorder, or SAD.

This series is about winter and mood. Part 1 covers what SAD is, how to tell it apart from ordinary winter low energy, and why light is the first and best-studied treatment. Part 2 looks at vitamin D and omega-3. Part 3 is about the carbohydrate cravings that come with dark days.

As always, I will tell you what holds up and what does not. There is a lot of confident advice about winter mood online, and some of it is wrong.

What SAD Is, and What It Is Not

Seasonal affective disorder was first described as a distinct condition in 1984, by Norman Rosenthal and colleagues at the US National Institute of Mental Health. It was added to the psychiatric diagnostic manual a few years later as a “seasonal pattern” of depression.

The key word is depression. SAD is not just feeling a bit flat in January. To meet the diagnosis, a person has episodes of major depression that:

  • start at the same time of year (usually autumn or winter),
  • lift at the same time of year (usually spring),
  • and have followed that pattern for at least two years in a row.

How common is it? It depends on how you count. In the US, estimates for the full disorder range from about 0.5% to 2.4% of adults. In Canada, estimates are in a similar range. A much larger group, perhaps 10 to 15% of people in northern regions, has milder seasonal symptoms that do not meet the full diagnosis. That milder version is what most people call the winter blues.

It is more common in women and in young adults, and it tends to ease with age.

The winter pattern looks different from ordinary depression

This part surprises people. Typical depression often brings poor sleep and poor appetite. Winter SAD usually does the opposite:

  • Sleeping much more, sometimes 10 or more hours, and still waking tired
  • Craving carbohydrates, especially sweets and starches
  • Weight gain over the winter
  • A heavy, leaden feeling in the arms and legs
  • Pulling away from people, the urge to hibernate
  • Losing interest in things that normally bring pleasure

If that list sounds like a bear preparing for winter, that is not a bad way to think about it. The body seems to be responding to short days as if it should slow everything down.

Winter blues or SAD: the practical test

The simplest question is: how much of your life is affected?

Winter blues: you feel lower, slower, and less motivated, but you still get to work, keep up with friends, and enjoy things, even if less than usual.

SAD: most of the day, most days, for weeks, it affects your work, your relationships, your ability to take care of yourself and your home. Very few things still bring joy.

See a doctor if: your low mood lasts most of the day, most days, for two weeks or more; you are missing work, appointments or deadlines; you cannot get out of bed; you are turning to alcohol for comfort; or you have any thoughts of death or suicide. If you are having thoughts of suicide, call or text 988 in the US, or your local emergency number, right away.

Why Dark Days Change Mood

The main theory behind winter SAD is about the body clock.

Your circadian rhythm is set each day mainly by light entering your eyes, especially morning light. When mornings are dark, the clock tends to drift later. Melatonin, the hormone that tells your body it is night, keeps being released later into the morning, which may explain the heavy, groggy start to the day.

There is good evidence for this. A 2001 study from the US National Institute of Mental Health found that people with SAD produced melatonin for a longer stretch of the night in winter than in summer, much as many animals do to track the seasons. Healthy volunteers in the same study did not show that seasonal change. In other words, people with SAD seem to respond more strongly to the short days.

Serotonin, the brain chemical involved in mood, also appears to vary by season, and light seems to affect it. The full picture is still being worked out, and I would be cautious of anyone who explains SAD with a single chemical. But the direction of the evidence is clear: light is doing something important.

Latitude Matters, but Less Than You Think

It is often said that SAD rises steadily the farther you live from the equator. The truth is more interesting.

A well-known 1999 review found that SAD was about twice as common in North America as in Europe, and that the link with latitude was clear in North America but not significant when all studies were considered together. The authors concluded that climate, genes and culture probably matter more than latitude alone.

Northern Norway is a good example. In Tromsø, the sun does not rise for about two months in winter, yet rates of winter depression are lower than many people would expect. A 2020 study by Kari Leibowitz and Joar Vittersø surveyed people across Norway and found that the farther north they lived, the more positively they viewed winter, and that people with a more positive “wintertime mindset” reported greater life satisfaction. The study cannot prove cause and effect, but it fits what you see there: winter treated as a season with its own pleasures, not just something to endure.

The Nordic idea of hygge belongs here too: warm light, simple food, and people gathered together in the late afternoon as darkness falls. Low-cost, social, and cosy.

Chinese medicine has its own version of this. Winter in the Neijing is the season of 藏 (cáng), storing. It asks us to 去寒就温, “leave the cold and move toward warmth,” and to keep the mind quiet, as if keeping something precious to ourselves. That is not a recipe for misery. It is permission to live more quietly in winter, and to do it on purpose.

Light: The First and Best-Studied Treatment

Here is where the old advice to wait for the sunlight meets modern psychiatry.

Bright light therapy is the standard first treatment for winter SAD. A 2005 meta-analysis in the American Journal of Psychiatry found that bright light reduced SAD symptoms with a large effect, comparable to many antidepressant drug trials. Dawn simulation, a light that gradually brightens before you wake, also helped.

How to use a light box

These are the standard recommendations, and I would follow them closely:

  • Brightness: 10,000 lux at your eyes. Much dimmer boxes need far longer sessions.
  • Timing: within the first hour after waking. Morning is the point.
  • Duration: about 20 to 30 minutes a day. Start at the low end.
  • Distance: usually 16 to 24 inches from your face, depending on the device. Follow the maker’s guide.
  • Eyes open, but do not stare into the light. Eat breakfast or read beside it.
  • UV filtered. Choose a box designed for SAD that filters out ultraviolet light. You do not need UV to get the benefit, and you do not want it.
  • Start before symptoms settle in. Many people begin in early autumn.

Light therapy is safe for most people, but it is not for everyone:

  • Bipolar disorder: light can trigger hypomania or mania. Use it only under a doctor’s supervision.
  • Eye conditions such as glaucoma, cataracts or diabetic eye disease: check with an eye doctor first.
  • Medications that increase light sensitivity: ask your doctor or pharmacist.
  • Side effects such as headache, eye strain or feeling “wired” usually settle if you shorten the session or sit a little farther away.

Outdoor light counts, even on a cloudy day

Here is a number that changed how I think about winter mornings. Ordinary indoor lighting is often only a few hundred lux. Outside on an overcast winter day, light levels commonly reach thousands of lux, often ten times brighter than your living room, or more. On a bright day, it can be far higher.

So a morning walk, even under grey skies, gives your body clock a much stronger signal than sitting by a lamp indoors. Add movement and you get two benefits at once. If a brisk walk is too much, gentle movement such as tai chi or stretching outdoors still counts.

Other Treatments That Work

Light is not the only option, and for some people it is not the best one.

Cognitive behavioural therapy for SAD (CBT-SAD). This is talk therapy adapted for winter depression. It helps people notice and change the thought patterns and habits (such as withdrawing and staying in) that make winter harder. In a trial of 177 adults led by Kelly Rohan at the University of Vermont, CBT-SAD and light therapy worked equally well in the first winter. Two winters later, 27% of the CBT group had a recurrence, compared with 46% of the light therapy group. One reason: by the second winter, only about 30% of people were still using their light box. CBT’s skills stay with you.

Medication. In 2006, the US FDA approved extended-release bupropion to help prevent winter depressive episodes in people with a history of SAD, usually started in autumn before symptoms begin. SSRI antidepressants are also used. These are decisions to make with a doctor, and they can be very effective.

Combination. For many people, the best results come from combining approaches: light, movement, a steady schedule, CBT skills, and medication when needed.

A Winter Light Routine

If you tend to feel low in winter, here is a simple plan to start in autumn:

  • Get up at the same time every day, weekends included. A regular wake time anchors the body clock.
  • Get outside in the first hour or two after waking. Even 15 to 20 minutes on a cloudy day helps.
  • Consider a 10,000 lux light box if mornings are dark or you cannot get outside, and follow the guidance above.
  • Keep moving, ideally outdoors in daylight.
  • Plan something social, especially in the late afternoon when it gets dark. A shared meal counts.
  • Cut back on alcohol. It disrupts sleep and makes mood worse, and it is often what people reach for on dark evenings.
  • Treat winter as its own season. The Neijing asks us to rest more and store energy in winter. Going to bed earlier is not laziness. It is working with the season.

Where Karviva Fits In

No drink treats SAD, and I want to be very clear about that. Light, movement, therapy and, when needed, medication do.

What I can say is that food supports everything else. Winter pulls many of us toward heavy, sugary comfort food just when our energy is lowest, and the sugar highs and crashes can make the afternoon slump worse. A low-sugar, whole-plant drink with its fibre intact is one easy way to add plants to a winter day without adding a sugar spike. I cover the food side, and the carb cravings in particular, in Part 3.

These are foods and beverages, not medicines.

In Part 2, we look at the two supplements most often recommended for winter mood, vitamin D and omega-3, and what the largest trials actually found. The answer for vitamin D may surprise you.

Get Updates and Special Offers

Sign up to our newsletter Today!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Karviva healthy juice bottles with various fruit flavors

New Customers Offer!

15% OFF

Yeah? Sign Up for Our Newsletter, Get a Deal,